FirstPromoter and Sled get compared a lot, but they're really answering two different questions. FirstPromoter's pitch is "affiliates and customer referrals in one tool." Sled's pitch is "the cheapest, Polar-native affiliate tool that just works." Which one fits depends entirely on what you're trying to build.
This is the honest head-to-head. Disclosure: I build Sled. Read the comparison columns, not just my verdict, and if you genuinely need a built-in customer-referral program, FirstPromoter has a real edge that I'll call out plainly.

TL;DR
- Need affiliates AND a customer-refers-friend program in one tool? FirstPromoter is built for that dual model. Sled is affiliate-focused.
- Just need affiliates, want it cheap? Sled, $19/mo flat vs FirstPromoter's $49–$149/mo.
- On Polar.sh? Sled. FirstPromoter is Stripe-first (plus Recurly, Chargebee, Braintree, Paddle) with no native Polar.
- Both handle recurring commission and refund clawback.
- Sled is hosted proprietary software. It is not open source, not AGPL, and not self-hostable. FirstPromoter is closed SaaS too.
The real fork: affiliate program vs. dual referral system
This is the decision, so lead with it:
- FirstPromoter does both affiliate marketing (creators promoting you for commission) and customer referrals (your existing users referring friends for a reward), in one system. That dual model is its actual differentiator.
- Sled is focused on affiliate marketing done cleanly and cheaply, with Polar.sh as a first-class citizen.
If "I want my customers to refer friends and I want creator affiliates, managed together" describes you, FirstPromoter's dual system is a legitimate reason to pay more. If you just want an affiliate program, you're paying for a half you won't use.
Side-by-side
| Sled | FirstPromoter | |
|---|---|---|
| Entry price | $19/mo after a 10-day free trial | ~$49/mo (to ~$149) |
| Commission fee | None | None (MRR caps per plan) |
| Polar.sh | ✅ Native | ❌ |
| Stripe | ✅ | ✅ |
| Recurly / Chargebee / Braintree / Paddle | Paddle via native signed webhooks. No native Recurly, Chargebee, or Braintree. | ✅ |
| Paddle | ✅ Native signed webhooks (Paddle-Signature) |
Limited |
| Affiliate program | ✅ | ✅ |
| Customer referral program | ❌ | ✅ Built-in |
| Recurring commission | ✅ | ✅ |
| Refund clawback | ✅ | ✅ |
| How you run it | Hosted by Sled. Not open source, not AGPL, not self-hosted. | Hosted SaaS |
FirstPromoter's price band in this table is from earlier 2026 notes and was not re-checked on 3 November 2026. Confirm it on their site. Sled's price is $19/mo or $99/yr.
Where FirstPromoter is genuinely better
- The dual affiliate + customer-referral system. If you want both motions in one dashboard, FirstPromoter is purpose-built and Sled doesn't compete here.
- More billing-gateway integrations out of the box (Recurly, Chargebee, Braintree alongside Stripe) which matters if you're on a legacy subscription billing stack.
- Mature feature surface. It's been around, and it's broad. Larger programs with complex commission rules will find more knobs.
If you're a more established SaaS on Chargebee or Recurly that wants affiliates and customer referrals in one place, FirstPromoter earns its higher price.
Where Sled wins
- Polar.sh native. FirstPromoter doesn't support Polar; Sled was built for it.
- Price. $19/mo flat after a 10-day free trial, roughly a third of FirstPromoter's entry tier.
- No MRR caps to babysit. FirstPromoter's plans tier by tracked MRR; Sled's flat price doesn't punish you for growing.
- Hosted, and only hosted. Sled is proprietary software at usesled.com. There is no AGPL license and no self-hosted edition.
- Simplicity. If you only need affiliates, Sled is the whole tool with none of the dual-system overhead. Paddle is a native signed webhook, the same shape as Polar and Stripe.
The honest verdict
- You want affiliates + customer referrals in one tool: FirstPromoter. Sled doesn't do customer-referral programs.
- You're on Polar.sh: Sled. FirstPromoter has no Polar support.
- You just want an affiliate program, cheaply: Sled, at a third of the price.
- You're on Recurly/Chargebee/Braintree: FirstPromoter's native gateway support is the easier path.
Different tools for different jobs. The trap is paying FirstPromoter's dual-system price for a single-system need, that's exactly the founder Sled is built for.
Frequently asked questions
Does FirstPromoter support Polar.sh?
No. FirstPromoter is Stripe-first with Recurly, Chargebee, Braintree, and Paddle support, but no native Polar.sh. For Polar billing, use a Polar-native tool like Sled.
What's the difference between an affiliate program and a customer-referral program?
Affiliate programs pay external creators commission for driving customers. Customer-referral programs reward your existing customers for referring friends. FirstPromoter does both; Sled focuses on affiliates. If you need both motions managed together, that's FirstPromoter's edge.
Is Sled cheaper than FirstPromoter?
Yes, $19/mo flat (with a 10-day free trial) versus FirstPromoter's ~$49–$149/mo with MRR caps. If you only need affiliates, the gap is hard to justify paying. Always check live pricing.
Can Sled do recurring commission like FirstPromoter?
Yes. Sled inherits subscription renewals so commission follows every recurring charge, and it reverses commission on refunds and chargebacks, the same recurring + clawback behavior you'd expect from FirstPromoter.
Is Sled open source?
No. Sled is proprietary hosted software. It is not open source, not AGPL, and not self-hostable. FirstPromoter is closed-source SaaS as well.
Just need a clean affiliate program on Polar, Stripe, or Paddle, without paying for a dual referral system you won't use? Sled is $19/mo or $99/yr after a 10-day trial, no commission fees. Start 10-day trial →